The Number One Reason People Join A Gym

Share this article


Everyone Thought That After Lockdown Gyms Would Struggle To Get People To Rejoin


Well, there’s a slight exception to that.  Some gyms, big commercials mainly, have seen a drop off in their membership numbers, while independents have seen a near record rejoin rate.  Some have even had to close their doors to new members as the gym was getting too crowded.


Why has this happened?  What dictates if a gym is successful in not only attracting members, but also keeping them.


Commercials have big join rates but also big attrition rates where members leave.  Independents tend to have lower attrition rates.  Why?

It's not the equipment and not the price that determines if members stay at their gym

Although both of those answers were present what was really interesting was that all the high scoring answers included this factor…


The community of people that went to the gym and the staff there

  • In fact 30% of people ​said they spent more time chatting to other members than working out
  • 48% of people said that their reason for remaining was positive interaction with staff.​​​​
  • 50% of people said location was the main factor so this was the number 1 factor but only just.

Source – runrepeat

Are you surprised by this data?

When I was competing and didn’t own my own gym I travelled across Bristol 5 days a week to train at a gym which was a 30 minute journey, that’s an extra hour of travelling as well as my 90 minutes training.

There were other gyms close to me but they didn't have the right atmosphere despite having similar equipment. I didn't feel at home.

biceps and triceps workout

I did have a membership to a local commercial gym as well for my morning cardio and as a ‘make do’ option when I couldn’t get to my main gym but the workouts there weren’t as good.

They didn’t like bodybuilders there, but ironically it wasn’t me leaving the weights out everywhere or being overly loud and obnoxious and hogging machines while texting like many of the people there.

That atmosphere just wound me up and despite that gym having good equipment it was populated by weapons grade belters.

I don’t remember anyone there being in decent shape, despite having the money to afford good nutrition and a PT for every session.  The community just was not geared towards results.

30 minutes away at a much smaller, independent gym and pretty much everyone was in decent shape.

They were all focussed on the goal – a better body

So they helped each other out, spotted when needed, made room on machines when people wanted to work in, gave each other a kick when motivation was flagging.

build a better body

Not everyone was a bodybuilder, but they were all focussed on building a better body.

That gym wasn’t short on members and had been there for over 15 years

The other gym is shut now

Community is such a powerful element, it can be the measure of your success (or failure)

While the right community lifts you up, the wrong community becomes the bucket of crabs

If you’ve not heard of this metaphor, put a load of crabs in a bucket and watch if one tries to get out.  All the other crabs will pull them back in.

They don’t want that crab to escape, to be better than them, to succeed where they have failed.

week of workouts

Instead of them all supporting each other to escape, they prefer to stop any forward thinkers or motivated individuals.

When I built my coaching community I focussed on creating a supportive online environment where everyone supports each other.  Because often it’s hard to find a community local to you. 

The online world has made this possible and with so much online negativity it’s nice to have a place that you can go to where everyone gets your journey.

That’s why the community members have such a high success rate (or part of the reason).

Is your fitness community supportive or limiting to your goals?

If it isn’t then make it your business to find one and watch your results and motivation go through the roof.



  • Seek out a gym that supports your efforts and creates positivity
  • Join an online community where everyone is focussed on the group doing well.

Check out my YouTube channel for more videos.

Use my Calorie Calculator to work out your calories for fat loss and get a free macro guide

Find out more about my coaching program to get you into your best shape ever

seb testimonial pic
testimonial jessica

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Linkdin
Share on Pinterest
Email to someone

Latest Podcasts and Articles

32. Does a Discount Mean Devaluing Your Coaching?

discounts run the risk of devaluing your coaching When should you offer discounts for your coaching? Should you ever offer discounts? Discounts run the risk of devaluing your coaching price.  Just like the DFS sale is always on, if you’re always offering discounts your price to value plummets. So how can you create an offer

Read More »

31. How You Put People Off Working With You

Things Online Fitness Coaches Do To Repel Clients That They Don’t Even Know They Are Doing You want to get more online fitness clients? But you’re not getting many leads for your coaching? Maybe you’re doing something that’s pushing them away. In this podcast, we discuss the common mistakes coaches make that repel clients, often

Read More »

30. Stop Clients Cancelling For Holidays

A client holiday shouldn’t mean a drop in income for you A big problem for fitness coaches – keeping clients when they will be away for a bit and want to cancel. Are your clients going on a holiday or just enjoying the time off work? Either way they may decide that they don’t need

Read More »

29. Is trying to have a process for everything slowing you down

Process procrastination Gurus seem to have a process for everything. Morning routines Lunch routines Ice bath routines Productivity Hacks Is all that really necessary? Is overthinking and over engineering basic daily routines harming your business? In this podcast you’ll learn what processes we follow in our business and personal lives. We’ll also discuss some of

Read More »

28. Reel Talk – Instagram Reel Strategies

Creating short form videos that attract your ideal customers What are the best practices for Reels at the moment for online fitness coaches? Dan and Tom share what they are currently doing and what’s working for them and their clients. We cover: Scripting content for clearer messaging Ways to create different types of Reels, Shorts

Read More »

27. How to get more clients in a week

Need more clients in the next 7-10 days? Do these things What we would do if we needed to get more clients fast.   Which sounds kind of silly as wouldn’t we always want more clients? So wouldn’t we do these all the time?   These are techniques which we apply to our coaching periodically

Read More »

Leave a comment

How can I help ?

Please fill in this form and I'll be in touch within 48 hours